Introduction: Why the Welding Process Determines Everything
In large-scale pipeline and structural engineering, selecting the appropriate type of welded steel pipe is the critical first step for project success and safety. The three major categories of welded steel pipes are SSAW (Spiral Submerged Arc Welded), ERW (Electric Resistance Welded), and LSAW (Longitudinal Submerged Arc Welded). Their most fundamental distinctions lie not in their final application, but in their manufacturing processes and the resulting weld characteristics. The weld seam is the pipe's most critical structural point, and its location, length, and formation method directly determine the body's stress distribution, geometric accuracy, and pressure-bearing capacity. This technical comparison guide delves into the physical differences between these three pipe types, helping you understand how to make informed selection decisions based on project requirements.
Part I: Weld Direction and Raw Material Define the Pipe Structure
The classification of welded steel pipes is primarily dictated by the direction of the weld seam and the form of the raw material.
1.1 LSAW: Longitudinal Straight Seam and Steel Plate Forming (The Longitudinal Standard)
-
Manufacturing Process: LSAW Pipe (Longitudinal Submerged Arc Welded Pipe) uses single, wide steel plates (Plate) as raw material. The plate is pre-bent and formed (often via UO, JCOE, or other processes) into a cylindrical shape. A straight weld seam is then applied along the axis of the pipe using Double-Sided Submerged Arc Welding (SAW).
-
Weld Characteristics: The seam is a straight, single longitudinal weld. Because thick plates are used, and the short weld length facilitates highly reliable Non-Destructive Testing (NDT), LSAW welds possess high quality and exceptional mechanical properties, making them superior in pressure-bearing and fatigue resistance among the three types.
1.2 SSAW: Spiral Weld Seam and Continuous Coil Forming (The Helical Solution)
-
Manufacturing Process: SSAW Pipe (Spiral Submerged Arc Welded Pipe) utilizes hot-rolled steel coil (Strip/Coil) as its raw material. The strip is continuously fed into a forming machine, and by adjusting the forming angle, it is spirally coiled. The seam is then continuously welded along the helical path using Double-Sided Submerged Arc Welding.
-
Weld Characteristics: The seam is helical (spiral), wrapping around the pipe body. While the weld length is longer, its orientation is diagonal to the principal stresses (hoop stress and axial stress) caused by internal pressure. This orientation helps to distribute stress concentration, giving SSAW unique advantages in large diameter fluid transmission.
1.3 ERW: High-Frequency Straight Seam and Resistance Welding (The High-Efficiency Seam)
-
Manufacturing Process: ERW Pipe (Electric Resistance Welded Pipe) starts with a steel coil. The coil is continuously roll-formed into an open tube shape. The edges of the tube blank are then heated by High-Frequency Current (HFI/HFW) to a molten state, and finally, the edges are forged together by squeeze rollers to complete the weld, without the addition of any filler metal.
-
Weld Characteristics: The seam is a straight longitudinal weld, parallel to the pipe axis. The weld is narrow, and the internal/external flash (excess material) can be removed, resulting in very high surface accuracy and low residual stress.
Part II: Key Differences in Performance, Specification, and Cost
The structural and process differences directly translate into distinct performance profiles for each pipe type.
| Comparative Feature | SSAW (Spiral Welded Pipe) | LSAW (Longitudinal Welded Pipe) | ERW (High-Frequency Welded Pipe) |
| Raw Material | Steel Coil (Continuous Strip) | Individual Steel Plate | Steel Coil (Continuous Strip) |
| Welding Method | Double-Sided Submerged Arc Welding (SAW) | Double-Sided Submerged Arc Welding (SAW) | High-Frequency Resistance Welding (HFW/HFI) |
| Weld Direction | Helical (Spiral) | Longitudinal (Straight) | Longitudinal (Straight) |
| Diameter Range | Wide (Easy to manufacture Large Diameter: 20" ~ 100"+) | Medium-Large Diameter (16" ~ 60"+) | Small to Medium Diameter (1/2" ~ 24") |
| Wall Thickness | Medium | Thickest (Up to 80mm) | Thin to Medium (Up to approx. 20mm) |
| Geometric Accuracy | Lower (Difficult to control during continuous forming) | Best (Ensured by UOE/JCOE processes) | Excellent (High dimensional precision) |
| Residual Stress | Higher (Continuous forming, no post-weld expansion) | Lower (UOE process includes expansion) | Lowest (Continuous, high-frequency weld) |
| Production Efficiency | Highest (Continuous feeding and production) | Moderate (Batch production from plates) | High (Continuous production) |
| Cost Efficiency | Good (High raw material utilization) | Highest (For high-pressure, high-risk projects) | Best (For general, low-to-medium pressure pipe) |
Part III: Application Positioning and Limitations: How to Make the Choice
Due to their structural and performance variations, these three types of welded steel pipes have clear market positioning.
3.1 LSAW: The Choice for High-Risk and High-Pressure
LSAW pipe's high strength, superior geometric accuracy, and short, easily inspectable straight weld make it the preferred choice for high-grade API 5L line pipe (e.g., PSL2, X70, X80).
-
High-Pressure Oil and Gas Trunk Lines: Especially in high-risk areas, deep sea, or densely populated regions where safety and toughness requirements are paramount.
-
Large Structures: Structural pipe required to bear immense loads.
To understand the detailed technical requirements for LSAW in high-pressure applications, please refer to: 【Anchor: API 5L LSAW Steel Pipe: Critical Selection for High-Pressure Oil & Gas...】
3.2 ERW: The Balance of Versatility and Economy
ERW steel pipe is characterized by its lower cost, high production speed, and smooth surface finish, making it ideal for high-volume, general-purpose applications:
-
Urban Distribution Networks: Such as municipal gas pipe and water pipe lines.
-
Structural Tubing: Fencing, scaffolding, and general mechanical structures.
-
Cost-Sensitive Conveyance: Low-pressure fluid transport.
For a deeper look into ERW pipe specifications and its role in ASTM A135/A53 standards, please consult: 【Anchor: ERW Steel Pipe Technology Explained: Advantages, Applications, and ASTM A135/A53 Standards Analysis】
3.3 SSAW: The Economic Option for Large Diameter and Long Distance
SSAW pipe is strategically advantageous in areas that demand large diameter and long-distance conveyance, where the specific stress concentration of the weld seam is not the absolute top priority. This is due to its flexible diameter adjustment and efficient material utilization.
-
Water Conservancy Projects: Large diameter water supply and drainage systems.
-
Piling Foundations: Piling pipes for bridges, wharves, and wind turbine foundations.
-
Oil/Gas Low-Risk Lines: Transporting crude oil and natural gas in remote or lower-risk pipeline segments.
To explore the cost and design advantages of SSAW in large diameter projects, please see: 【Anchor: Large Diameter Spiral Welded Pipe (SSAW): Length, Diameter, and Cost Advantages】
Conclusion
SSAW, ERW, and LSAW each offer a distinct balance of welding technology, structural properties, and economics. LSAW represents the highest standard of quality and safety assurance, ERW offers the highest efficiency and cost-effectiveness, and SSAW strikes a balance point in large diameter and long-distance transmission. Correct selection requires a comprehensive evaluation of the project's pressure rating, fluid type, operating environment, and budget constraints.
For the strategic positioning of these three welded pipes within the larger supply chain and a review of more detailed technical parameters, please return to our definitive guide: 【【Definitive Guide】SSAW, ERW, and LSAW Welded Steel Pipe Full Analysis: Manufacturing Processes, API 5L Standards, and Application Selection Strategy】
